Archive for the ‘teachers unions’ Tag

Teacher Unions: Two sides to every story   2 comments

Going through my Twitter stream, I see this article: Black parents vs. the Teachers’ Union. First thought: What the (bleep)? Are they serious? Have we come to using the union as the Boogeyman to scare parents into leaving public schools and adding their child’s name to a long-arse waiting list at a *charter school? Seriously? Quite frankly, the union and teacher-bashing is tired and played-out because it solves no-thing…absolutely no-thing! For those of us who keep-up with the monumental changes in education, we know what’s happening: Right before our eyes, public education is rapidly becoming privatized by people with the big checkbooks. Sure, education needs serious reform but money is not the primary (or even secondary) solution to what ails our system. Top-down reform is needed now. What’s even scarier: Our president appointed a man with no classroom experience to make these monumental decisions. For those who insist that one need not have classroom experience to lead our country’s education system, please refer to all of the research on the debacle ‘miracle’ in Chicago. And then get back to me.

As someone who has worked in a state without a teachers’ union, I can attest to the horrible and toxic working conditions (not referring to kids) in some of Georgia’s schools. I have seen teachers get cursed out by administrators, in front of students. And we wonder why kids think that type of behavior is acceptable. I have witnessed teachers get harassed by principals and other teachers for no other reason than the simple fact they were excellent teachers. You know when you come into an organization that accepts mediocrity as the standard, you are asking for trouble when you raise the bar for your students and colleagues. No, I am not making-up these stories; my left-brain is an underachiever. I couldn’t make-up this stuff even if I tried. Or wanted to. Ask any teacher working in a non-union state if they’d prefer to have some form of organized and committed representation. I am sure they’d say ‘Yes.’ But then again, that’s just me basing my assumption on what I have seen and experienced. I have yet to come across any horror stories about unions from teachers. If anyone reading this knows of any, I would certainly appreciate links. If that’s not argument enough, look at the most recent NAEP data. Which states performed in the top and bottom ten? Union or non-union states? I already know the answer.

So we can’t get the support we need by pitting teachers against (Black) parents, teachers against teachers, and labeling overworked and inadequately supported teachers as ineffective, so we start using scare tactics to convince Black parents that unions and public schools will be the downfall of education. (NOTE: Education failed Black and Brown kids years ago.) Where were these arguments 9-10 years ago before NCLB? How about 10-15 years before that? It’s ironic how, now that billions of additional dollars are at play, institutions that have been around to protect the rights of workers (that is the purpose of a union) are now being used as a scapegoat for everything that’s wrong with public education? When will school, district, and state administrators be forced to own-up to their roles in under-staffed schools, inadequate instructional resources, and piss-poor professional development? There’s enough blame to go around in this crisis. Let’s share the wealth. Besides, the last time I checked, teachers and unions do not vote on curriculum, education policy, budgets, etc. Those decisions are made by local and state boards of education. I guess I am the only one who sees that. Perhaps I need my eyes checked. On second thought, nah. I know there are teachers who would be saying the same things if they didn’t fear losing their jobs. Alas, they don’t have the 1st Amendment protection like teachers who belong to a union. Sucks to be them.

As we (true educators) say: Those who can, teach. Those who can’t, go to the central office.

*I am not anti-charter. I support charter schools that stick to the original intent of the idea, not those that choose to only open in districts where at least 70% of students qualify for Free and Reduced Lunch, or those that lock groups into 99-year lease agreements making it nearly impossible to end the ‘business’ relationship.